Skip to main content

Fall is a beautiful season, but it also means the leaves from trees will start falling and accumulating in your gutters. Gutter guards are an excellent solution to prevent clogs and save you time and money on cleaning. This article discusses the different types of gutter guards available, their pros and cons, and which one is best suited for leaves. It also explores the advantages and disadvantages of DIY versus professional installation.

Understanding the Importance of Gutter Guards for Fall Cleanup

If you live in an area with trees, you may have experienced the frustration of cleaning your gutters from all the leaves and debris that clog up the system. This is where gutter guards come in handy! Gutter guards are designed to prevent leaves and debris from accumulating in your gutters, saving you time and money on cleaning or hiring a professional.

But have you ever wondered why trees shed their leaves in the fall? It’s actually a self-protection mechanism. Evergreen plants have thick waxes and resins to protect their leaves from freezing and fracturing during winter, while deciduous species have thin leaves that are susceptible to cold temperatures. To prevent damage, these plants shed their leaves and enter dormancy, conserving energy for the spring.

As the seasons change, hormones within the plant activate the abscission process, which separates the leaves from the plant without leaving an open wound. The abscission layer slowly cuts the leaf from the plant, and the leaves fall, leaving your gutters free from debris. Gutter guards make fall cleanup a breeze and protect your gutters from clogging.

Best Gutter Guards for Leaves

Types of Gutter Guards: Which Ones Are Best for Leaves?

There are five main types of gutter guards that you can choose from, each with its own strengths and features.

Mesh gutter guards

First up, we have mesh gutter guards, which are made of metal sheets with tiny holes that keep out debris while allowing water to flow through. They are durable and can be installed on various types of gutters and roofs, making them a popular choice for homeowners.


Next, we have bottle brush gutter guards, which are cylindrical in shape and look like wire cleaning brushes. They are DIY-friendly and great at filtering out large debris like leaves while allowing air to circulate to help the gutters dry out and prevent rusting. They are also affordable and easy to clean.


Screen gutter guards are another option, made of metal or plastic. They are affordable and easy to install, but keep in mind that regular screen protection may not be as effective at filtering out small debris compared to fine mesh. Metal screen guards can also rust and stain your home, so plastic versions may be a better choice.


Foam gutter guards, also known as foam gutter inserts, fit inside your gutters and block all debris from entering while allowing water to penetrate through pores. They are DIY-friendly but may need to be replaced every two years, which can add up in costs over time.

Reserve Curve

Lastly, we have reverse curve gutter guards, which have been around for over a century but still have some issues. They can be difficult to install properly, hard to remove for cleaning and maintenance, and may accumulate debris over time. They are also visible from the ground, so you may need to pick a color that matches your roof. Additionally, some sources claim that they may not perform well in heavy rains and can promote the formation of large icicles during winter.

Comparing the Pros and Cons of Different Gutter Guard Materials for Leaves

When choosing gutter guards or gutter cover systems, it’s important to consider the pros and cons, keeping in mind your home’s location and surrounding vegetation. If you have trees around your home that shed a lot of leaves and organic material, it’s crucial to do a thorough home examination before making a decision.

Let’s start with the pros of gutter guards and cover systems.

  • First, they can help you avoid clogged downspouts, which minimizes water damage and maintenance issues in the future. Clogged downspouts can cause water to overflow and pool on your roof or gutters, leading to leaks and water damage.
  • Gutter guards also make maintenance easier, as they reduce the amount of debris that accumulates in your gutters, making it simpler to clean them out periodically.
  • Plus, they can improve the aesthetics of your home by preventing organic matter from piling up and making your gutters look cleaner and more streamlined.
  • However, there are also a few cons to keep in mind.
  • There’s no one-size-fits-all perfect gutter guard or cover system, as their effectiveness depends on the amount of water coming off your roof and the roof surface area feeding into the gutter. 
  • If your gutter is already overwhelmed with water due to poor design or slope of the roof, adding a gutter guard may not solve the problem and could even make it worse.
  • Additionally, the more covered and protected your gutters are, the slower water flow will be. While the amount of debris may be less, selecting the wrong type of gutter guard for your specific needs could actually trap more debris and create a different type of problem.

DIY vs. Professional Installation: Which is Better for Gutter Guards for Leaves?

When deciding on installing new gutter guards, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of DIY versus professional installation. DIY installation may seem cost-effective, but there are risks to consider. Safety is a major concern, as slip and fall accidents can happen from ladders or roofs, especially for those without construction experience. Mistakes can also be costly, as DIYers may miss important nuances that could result in water damage to their homes. Additionally, manufacturer warranties may not cover DIY installations, leaving homeowners responsible for replacement costs.

On the other hand, professional installation offers several advantages. While the upfront cost may be higher, it reduces financial liability for injuries as workers are covered by the company’s insurance. Professional installers also often receive warranties from manufacturers and provide their own warranties for their work, giving homeowners added protection. Moreover, professionals are trained to do the job correctly, preventing water damage and other property issues. Dealing with stressful mistakes or property damage claims can be avoided by hiring a reputable gutter guard installation company.

How to Maintain Gutter Guards for Optimal Leaf-Free Performance

So, you’re looking to maintain your gutter guards for optimal leaf-free performance? Well, you’re in luck because HomeCraft Gutter Protection™ has got you covered! As one of the largest gutter guard companies in the Southeast, we have one of the most effective debris-blocking systems on the market. Here’s what you need to know:

Quality Matters: Not all gutter guards are created equal, so it’s important to do your research before making a decision. Our gutter guards are made from 304 marine-grade, stainless steel micro-mesh that’s built to last. The micro-mesh is finely woven to allow only water to enter your gutters, while the raised diamonds elevate debris so water can still flow freely.

Easy to Fit: Our gutter guards have a better design with a powder-coated aluminum frame and no substructures underneath the mesh screen. This means that the mesh can easily bend to fit various gutter-to-roof scenarios without impeding water flow. Plus, we offer a free estimate to ensure a perfect fit for your gutters.

Strong and Secure: We use reinforced hidden hangers to install our gutter guards, attaching them to your fascia boards. This ensures that your gutters will not pull away from your home, providing a sturdy and durable solution.

To maintain optimal performance, we recommend periodic inspections and cleaning if necessary, especially during peak leaf-fall seasons. Simply brush off any accumulated debris on the mesh surface with a soft brush or rinse with a hose. Our gutter guards are designed to keep your gutters clog-free and eliminate the need for regular gutter cleaning. With over 20,863 satisfied customers and 8,751 positive reviews, HomeCraft Gutter Protection™ is the better quality and better product solution for hassle-free gutters.

Gutter Guards vs. Leaf Blowers: Which Is More Effective for Leaves?

The gutter guards and leaf blowers are both effective for leaves but in different ways. Gutter guards prevent debris from getting into the gutters, reducing the need for frequent cleaning. However, they still need periodic examinations and cleaning. If you live in an area with a lot of trees and flying debris, installing gutter guards can help you cut back on the frequency and intensity of cleaning. Leaf blowers are a great tool for DIY gutter cleaning.

Using leaf blowers to clean gutters is pretty straightforward. You wait for them to dry as much as possible and then blow the debris out of them. You blow from side to side to avoid damaging the roof, walls, and windows. It’s best to blow in the opposite direction from the downpipe to avoid blocking it. Leaf blowers offer better safety than cleaning from the top of a ladder. Cleaning your gutters from the top of a ladder is a dangerous idea.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Installing Gutter Guards for Leaves

When installing gutter guards, there are common mistakes that you should avoid to ensure their effectiveness.

· One common mistake is spacing the gutter hangers too far apart. It is recommended to space the holders at a limit of three feet apart or two feet apart if you live in a cold environment.

· Another mistake is selecting the wrong type of gutter guard. Before making a purchase, you should consider your home’s unique requirements, such as the pitch of your roof, the size of your home, and the amount of precipitation your area typically gets.

·You should also avoid thinking that you can set and forget the gutter guard, as no gutter guard is maintenance-free.

 It is important to flush the gutters out from time to time, and you should choose a gutter guard that allows for easy flushing

 Choosing the wrong gutter guard for your situation can also be a mistake, so it’s important to select a guard that works best for your specific needs

Lastly, incorrect installation of downspouts can lead to leakage in the foundation and damage to the facade. Make sure to install downspouts properly and keep them 8 to 10 feet from your home’s structure.

Bottom Line

Wrapping up, gutter guards are an essential investment for homeowners who want to protect their gutters from clogs caused by leaves and debris. Understanding the various types of gutter guards available and the pros and cons of each is crucial to make an informed decision. When deciding between DIY and professional installation, safety, and cost are essential considerations, and the professional installation often offers added protection and peace of mind. With the right gutter guard system in place, fall cleanup can be a breeze, leaving you with clean, clog-free gutters and saving you time and money on maintenance and repairs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are gutter guards?

Gutter guards are devices designed to prevent leaves and debris from accumulating in your gutters, saving you time and money on cleaning or hiring a professional.

Why do trees shed their leaves in the fall?

Trees shed their leaves in the fall as a self-protection mechanism to prevent damage caused by cold temperatures. Hormones within the plant activate the abscission process, which separates the leaves from the plant without leaving an open wound.

What are the different types of gutter guards?

There are five main types of gutter guards: mesh gutter guards, bottle brush gutter guards, screen gutter guards, foam gutter guards, and reverse curve gutter guards.

What are the types of gutter guards best for leaves?

Mesh, brush, screen, foam, and reverse curve gutter guards are the five main types of gutter guards that you can choose from. Mesh and brush gutter guards are the most effective at filtering out large debris, while foam gutter guards are more effective at blocking all debris.

Is DIY or professional installation better for gutter guards?

The professional installation offers several advantages, such as insurance coverage for workers, manufacturer warranties, and added protection for homeowners. While DIY installation may seem cost-effective, it can be risky, and mistakes may result in costly water damage to homes.


Leave a Reply

Close Menu

Click to Hide Advanced Floating Content